Where does the TVT money go?

The Tajik weekly Facts & Comments published an article titled “Where does the TVT money go?” (#15, 07.07.2010).

The author, M. Salohiddinov says that due to the Tajik state television he has fallen in love with reading – since all the TV programs are dedicated only to the president’s business trips. Last week, the Tajik TV stations were covering president Rakhmon’s visit to Gorno-Badakhshan Autonomous Province.

“These stories are long as Arabian nights… and they do not require any special investments,” – the author says. – “It takes a lot of efforts, specialists and logistical arrangements to create a real talk show and touch upon something really topical. The TV authorities do not bother. They keep broadcasting these boring reportages, and they do not care about the audience’s opinion”.

NANSMIT monitoring servce

Is Russia Considering Returning To The Afghan Border?

Viktor Ivanov, the head of Russia’s Federal Drug Control Service, was in Tajikistan at the start of July and made a curious remark.

Ivanov said Russian border guards could return to duty in Tajikistan keeping a watch on the Central Asian country’s border with Afghanistan. It was a function the Russian border guards performed from 1991 until 2006, when they completely handed over the task to their Tajik counterparts.

Ivanov said Russia was not holding talks with Tajikistan on sending the Russian troops back but added, «if the countries have goodwill it is possible.» Ivanov made his comments just after meeting with Tajik President Emomali Rahmon.

It is no secret Russia, as well as other countries, are concerned about increasing drug trafficking from Afghanistan through Tajikistan and onward toward Russia and Europe or China and Asia.

Many in Russia and some of the Central Asian states were displeased to see the last of the Russian border guards leave the Tajik-Afghan border and feared the Tajik border guards were not up to the task.

Results since have been mixed. Seizures of narcotics are up, but many feel that simply reflects the fact that ever more narcotics are crossing the border and that the percentage of drugs intercepted remains only some 5 to 10 percent of the total.

Russia may have another reason for wanting to help Tajikistan keep watch on its southern frontier. Kyrgyzstan, to the north of Tajikistan, has been experiencing severe difficulties — the ouster of a president and violence between ethnic Kyrgyz and Uzbeks.

With instability both to the south and north, Tajikistan’s border guards are stretched thin, a situation that gives the «bad guys» — drug traffickers, Islamic militants, and others — easier access and freedom of movement in the southeastern Central Asian region.

Ivanov said the question was: are Russia and Tajikistan «ready to take this action»? Since Ivanov appears to have been the one talking about it, we can assume Russia at least is ready.

http://www.rferl.org/content/Is_Russia_Considering_Returning_To_The_Afghan_Border/2092083.html

New legal study guide for journalists

The Tajik National Association of Independent Media has released a new study guide for journalists titled “Legal Regulations in Access to Information”. The study guide was released under support of Internews in Tajikistan and funded by USAID.

The publication contains a compilation of legal documents regulating access to information with relevant explanations and interpretations. It also contains samples of legal complaints and other papers, which might help media professionals in their everyday activities. While working on the study guide, the authors referred to practical experience of Russian, Kazakh and Tajik researchers and legal practitioners.

The study guide is released in Tajik and Russian languages. It is intended for journalists, lawyers, media researchers and university students. The publication is being disseminated free of charge and can be received upon request at NANSMIT.

NANSMIT

NGO Says Journalists Were Attacked In Southern Kyrgyzstan

A Kyrgyz journalists’ organization says several journalists were attacked while covering the ethnic violence in the southern cities of Jalal-Abad and Osh last month, RFE/RL’s Kyrgyz Service reports.

The Public Association of Journalists (PAJ) said that six journalists were attacked and beaten in Osh, another suffered severe burns, and photographer Pazyle Sarybaev is still missing. In addition, the homes of four journalists were damaged after they were set on fire.

It added that Osh-based Keremet TV cameraman Batyr Mamatjanov, who was seriously injured on June 11 when a crowd attacked his car and seized his camera, remains in critical condition in hospital with broken ribs and a head injury.

PAJ coordinator Meri Bekeshova told RFE/RL the association has given financial and technical help to the journalists who suffered attacks, with assistance from International Media Support, a Danish nonprofit organization.

At least 291 people were killed and hundreds of thousands fled their homes in the clashes between ethnic Uzbeks and Kyrgyz in Osh and Jalal-Abad that began on June 10.

http://www.rferl.org/content/NGO_Says_Journalists_Were_Attacked_In_Southern_Kyrgyzstan/2089261.html

Freedom of Speech in Tajikistan, June 2010

This report is based upon messages from the Tajik media and the NANSMIT monitoring network.

In June 2010 the NANSMIT Monitoring Service received 16 reports. Five of them describe the factual situation in the media in the light of socio-legal and political environment; five reports describe direct violations of rights of media professionals; and six reports describe conflicts and accusations against the media and journalists.

I. PECULIARITIES OF POLITICAL, SOCIAL, ADMINISTRATIVE AND LEGAL CLIMATE IN THE COUNTRY DEFINING THE FACTUAL SITUATION IN THE MEDIA

1. Public speeches and statements of superior officials defining the factual situation in the mass media

June 3
Ibrohim Usmonov, chairman of the Tajik Media Council, Dushanbe

“Disrespect to women is manifested in this or that extent in 99 percent of publications in the Tajik media”, — said Ibrohim Usmonov, chairman of the Tajik Media Council. He made this remark on 3 June in Dushanbe at a round table on the topic “Studies of legal and moral reasons for bringing the Tajik media to judicial liability”.

According to Usmonov, the vast majority of publications present a woman as a servant to her husband, a prostitute, an avaricious creature seeking for easy money, etc. “The media do not publish stories presenting women as prominent politicians, successful entrepreneurs, or, say, simply a good journalist”, — he added.

June 25
All media, Dushanbe

Twenty newspapers and five magazines have been registered in the Ministry of Culture since the beginning of this year compared to 24 newspapers and 18 magazines during the same period of 2009.

All the five magazines are based in Dushanbe. The magazine “Navnikhol” will be printed once a month in Tajik, Russian and English languages. All these magazines are sectorial, i.e. their founders are ministries and government agencies.

Seven out of the twenty newspapers are sectorial; the rest of them are private. Nine newspapers will be published in Dushanbe; eight – in Sughd province; one in GBAO; and one in Rasht valley.

Experts note that very few magazines survive in the current conditions. Usually, shortly after registration they get closed, not being able to cope with numerous challenges, including the lack of experienced personnel.

2. Journalists protecting their civil and professional rights

June 17
All media, Dushanbe

On 16 June the Tajik Union of Journalists hosted a round table on the issues of access to information. The event was organized by the National Association of Independent Media (NANSMIT).

It was stressed that “Information cannot be divulged only if it contains elements of the state, banking or commercial secrets”. The Tajik Constitution, the “Law on printing and other mass media”, the “Law on Television and Radio” clearly explain that media professionals have the right to timely receive reliable and quality information.

June 28
All media, Dushanbe

On 28 June, the Institute for War and Peace Reporting (IWPR) held a seminar in Dushanbe on the topic “Interactions between state press services and the media”. The event was held within the framework of the project “Human rights and legal education through the media in Central Asia” financed by the European Commission and technically supported by the National Association of Independent Media (NANSMIT). NANSMIT is currently implementing another similar project — “Strengthening the media freedom network in Tajikistan” supported by Internews and funded by USAID.

The main purpose of the seminar is to improve access to official sources of information and develop practical skills of interaction between the state press services, NGOs and the media.

II. VIOLATION OF RIGHTS IN THE MEDIA

1. Obstructions to professional activities

June 10
Usmon Khushvakhtov, head of mayor’s office administration in Kulyab

The resent disastrous floods in Kulyab became the main topic of publications in the media. Usmon Khushvakhtov, head of the mayor’s office administration told the Ozodagon weekly (#25, 10.06.2010) that certain authors pursued their sordid goals defaming some public officials.

In particular, Khushvakhtov criticized the story published in Ozodagon on 12 May. The official says that the publication goes beyond the standards of media ethics. “Although the Constitution guarantees the freedom of speech, actions of certain individuals cannot go beyond the framework of laws”.

2. Violation of professional rights

19 June
Zarina Abduvakhidova, head of Persian service, Radio Ovozi Tojik, Dushanbe

Zarina Abduvakhidova, employee of the Radio Ovozi Tojik Persian service was sacked from the post of the head of the service and appointed to the position of editor, according to the Order issued by the chairman of the State TV and Radio Committee on 3 March 2010.

On 17 May, Ms. Abduvakhidova applied to the Ismoili Somoni district court in Dushanbe with a request to reinstate her in the former position and reimburse moral and material losses.

On 18 June, the Ismoili Somoni district court settled the suit in favor of the journalist. Abduvakhidova will be reinstated in her previous position. Besides that, the court obliged the TV & Radio Committee to pay the claimant the due amount as a compensation for illegal demotion.

This is a precedent of a kind – the case was resolved in favor of the journalist.

3. Ungrounded limitation in access to information

24 June
Kharamgul Kodiri, freelance journalist

Freelance journalist Kharamgul Kodiri complains in her article that Tajik parliamentarians hide from journalists (Nigokh weekly, #14, 23.06.2010). “They find all kind of excuses to avoid a meeting with media representatives”. Kodiri calls the Tajik parliament “The valley of dumbness”.

III. CONFLICTS. VIOLATIONS INCRIMINATED TO THE MEDIA AND JOURNALISTS

1. Protection of honor, dignity and business reputation

3 June
Millat weekly, Dushanbe

The Dushanbe city court sent the text of an article published in the Millat weekly to the Tajik Institute of Language and Literature for a linguistic expertise. The Ministry of Agriculture accused the newspaper of insult and defamation – because of the article titled “The Ministry of Agriculture is the most corrupt government institution”.

Junaid Ibodov, the lawyer representing the interests of Millat in court, said that the claim of the Ministry looks illogical since “insult” refers to the category of criminal cases. According to Article 136 of the Tajik Criminal Code, only individuals can be considered as victims of insult; and none of legal entities or institutions could be considered victims of insult or defamation.

The lawyer stated that the newspaper is going to appeal against the court decision since it contradicts the Tajik legislation.

This report is based on compiled materials from the media and private information presented by correspondents of the NANSMIT Monitoring Network

Coordinator of the Monitoring Service
Abdufattokh Vokhidov

Project Manager
Nuriddin Karshibaev

TOL Summer Courses – Journalism and New Media training in Prague

We still have a few places available on our summer courses inJuly and August. If you’re looking to develop your skills as ajournalist, in photography, or in new media, then TOL coursescan give you the training that you need.

1. NEW MEDIA FOR NGOS (July 11 — 16, 2010
Much more than just Facebook and Twitter.
Learn to spread yourmessage wider and faster, manage IT projects, improve internalefficiency and revamp your online strategy — even with a minimaltechnology budget.

2. INVESTIGATIVE JOURNALISM (July 18 — 23, 2010)Learn to put together a piece of investigative journalism, usesources and build a publishable case. The course featurestraining from three leading investigative journalists.

3. FOREIGN CORRESPONDENT COURSE (July 25 — August 2, 2010)Learn how to break into foreign reporting on this highly popularcourse. The trainers are all experienced correspondents, andyou will get a practical taste of international reporting — researching, writing and filing your own story from Prague.

4. PHOTOJOURNALISM (August 2 — 7, 2010)Spend five days in Prague learning the ropes of photojournalism.The course is split roughly 50:50 into classroom trainingsessions and practical shooting and editing sessions.

For more details about the courses visit our training website:

http://www.tol.org/client/training/open-courses/ Alternatively, please contact plockovaj@tol.org if you’d likefurther information.

tp://www.tol.org/client/training/open-courses/ Alternatively, please contact plockovaj@tol.org if yo

EU Envoy Warns Of Regional Risk From Kyrgyz Instability

BRUSSELS — The top EU envoy for Central Asia has warned that recent instability in the south of Kyrgyzstan could spill over into other countries along the Ferghana Valley.

Pierre Morel, the EU special representative for the region, also said the EU wants the referendum on Kyrgyzstan’s new constitution to go ahead as planned on June 27.

Morel made his comments before the European Parliament’s foreign affairs committee in Brussels today.

The hour-long question-and-answer session was the first public appearance of the veteran EU envoy after a fact-finding visit to Kyrgyzstan last week.

His audience consisted of a dozen or so scattered EU deputies struggling to use up their allotted speaking time.
Morel — who said he had left a meeting of EU ambassadors busy «mobilizing resources» for Kyrgyzstan — sought to impress on his listeners the gravity of the situation.

The situation is “difficult, very difficult, because apart from the future of the country, it puts into question the security and stability of the entire Central Asian region,» Morel said.

Regional stability is an important EU policy objective, given Central Asia’s significant energy resources and proximity to Afghanistan.

Morel said there has been too little EU engagement with Kyrgyzstan in the past, despite the country’s attempts to break with authoritarianism. Only France and Germany have embassies in Bishkek, and an EU delegation was established only in February.

Blame Placed On Bakiev

The EU envoy blamed the «clan» of ex-President Kurmanbek Bakiev, ousted in April after a popular revolt, for fomenting the unrest in Kyrgyzstan’s south earlier this month which saw scores of people killed in clashes between ethnic Uzbeks and Kyrgyz.

Morel said Bakiev’s loyalists, led by his brother, made a «concerted effort» to provoke the clashes in a bid to regain power. Bakiev, who is now in Belarus, has denied any connection to the violence.

Morel said that during his trip he spoke to civil society activists who had been on the ground in Osh during the turmoil.

He also noted the presence of drug gangs and Islamic extremists in the southern cities of Osh and Jalal-Abad.

Another factor, Morel said, was the «lack of attention and effort» from Bishkek, and the inadequacies of the local law enforcement forces, which were overrun, with many police killed.

The EU diplomat said the bloc is now looking for a «role» in the country alongside the United Nations and the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE), without «duplicating» the work of either.

Morel said the EU’s focus is on fostering democracy in Kyrgyzstan. «The message of the European Union is very clear. We call for a road map for a return to democracy. First, public order; second, the rule of law: and, third, a return to a genuinely democratic constitution,» he said.

Morel said the EU wants the June 27 referendum on a new constitution to go ahead.

He noted the constitution — with elections to follow in October — will not usher in a fully parliamentary system, but a «mixed» one where a popularly elected president still has wide powers.

But, Morel said, the elements of parliamentarianism in the new constitution should «balance» the president’s role and break what he called the «Kyrgyz cycle» of street protests against autocratic rulers being usurped by clan leaders acting in their own narrow self-interest.

The EU has released 5 million euros ($6.14 million) in humanitarian aid, and another 6 million is in the pipeline for electoral support and civil society initiatives.

Ahto Lobjakas, REE/RL

Источник: http://www.rferl.org/content/EU_Envoy_Warns_Of_Regional_Risk_From_Kyrgyz_Instability/2080537.html

Kazakh Journalist Detained For Staging Protest

Kazakh police have detained journalist Yekaterina Belyaeva for holding an unsanctioned protest, RFE/RL’s Kazakh Service reports.

Belyaeva, who works for the Almaty-based newspaper «Vzglyad» (Look), came to the city’s Independence Square on June 21 and unfolded a sign saying: «President, Give Us Back Our Constitution!»

She told journalists who came to the square that she was protesting the constitutional law on the «Leader of the Nation» that was adopted last week.

The new law bestowed on President Nursultan Nazarbaev the title Leader of the Nation and gave him immunity from prosecution. In addition, his property and that of members of his family cannot be confiscated.

Several police officers took the sign from Belyaeva by force and told her that she did not have permission to stage a protest. Belyaeva answered that she has permission in accordance with Kazakhstan’s Constitution, which guarantees freedom of assembly.

Rights activist Ghalym Ageleuov tried to intervene and help Belyaeva, but he was forced by a policeman to the edge of the square. Belyaeva was pushed into a police car and driven away.

Prominent journalist Sergei Duvanov and rights activist Andrei Sviridov were fined for a similar protest action last week.

Kazakhstan currently holds the chairmanship of the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe, whose mandate includes such issues as human rights and freedom of the press.

http://www.rferl.org/content/Kazakh_Journalist_Detained_For_Staging_Protest/2078620.html

New legislation to provide exemplary protection for freedom of information in Island

Iceland’s parliament, the Alpinghi, has unanimously approved a resolution known as the Icelandic Modern Media Initiative (IMMI) that calls on the government to draft legislation in line with its recommendations for the protection of media, journalists and bloggers.

Reporters Without Borders hails this ambitious and positive initiative, adopted on 15 June, and calls on the government to do its utmost to respect the parliament’s will when it drafts the law.

“This proposal is on the right track,” Reporters Without Borders said. “It regards freedom of expression as a fundamental right and would create optimal conditions for investigative journalism. Even if the precise impact of this proposed law remains to be seen, especially as regard journalists’ legal protection, Iceland has established itself as a pioneer.”

The press freedom organisation added: “We hope this will serve as an example to other governments. It is certainly a promising departure from the general tendency, especially in democratic countries, for press freedom to be eroded and for harassment of journalists and their sources to increase.”

Assembling elements from the best legislation in the world, Iceland wants to become a global safe haven for journalists and new media that are being threatened or harassed and want to take advantage of the best protection available anywhere.

The transparency and independence of news and information are the initiative’s keywords. The declared aims are “to strengthen freedom of expression around world and in Iceland, as well as providing strong protections for sources and whistleblowers” (see the IMMI website). It also aims to secure communications and protect journalists and bloggers from unwarranted defamation suits both in Iceland and abroad.

Iceland wants to be seen as the ideal place for online media and data storage banks to locate their servers in order to shield themselves from the threats of censorship, filtering and closure, and to provide the best protection for the personal data of their users.

The initiative came about partly in response to a press issue that had a lot of impact in Iceland. In August 2009, the RUV television station was prevented at the last moment from broadcasting a story about Kaupthing Bank, which was immersed in a financial crisis.

The story was based on information from Wikileaks, which specialises in getting confidential information from whistleblowers in return for guarantees of anonymity, and which had already published extracts from the bank’s accounts. An injunction obtained by Kaupthing Bank prevented RUV from broadcasting the item, but the station told its viewers what had happened.

Read the article: http://en.rsf.org/islande-nouvel-article-18-06-2010,37771.html

Lucie Morillon
Reporters Without Borders
Head of the New Media Desk
internet@rsf.org
Skype : rsfnet
Twitter: luciemorillon and RSF_RWB
T : +33 1 44 83 84 71

http://en.rsf.org/islande-nouvel-article-18-06-2010,37771.html

INTERNATIONAL CRISIS GROUP — NEW MEDIA RELEASE

Brussels/New York, 17 June 2010:

To: Security Council Ambassadors

Your Excellency,

We urge the United Nations Security Council to take immediate steps to address the ongoing crisis in Kyrgyzstan. With a death toll likely to reach far higher than the official count of 200 and an estimated 400,000 displaced in Kyrgyzstan and across the border in Uzbekistan, the situation poses a significant threat to international peace and security. The Kyrgyz authorities have primary responsibility for halting the violence and resolving this crisis, but reports from the ground provide ample evidence that the government is unable to protect those in need, and Kyrgyz authorities have already acknowledged that they need substantial assistance.

In the past week, violence along ethnic lines has engulfed Osh and Jalal-Abad, resulting in killings, rapes, beatings, and widespread burning and looting of homes and other properties. There are a growing number of reports that Kyrgyz military and other security personnel not only failed to stop the violence, but in some cases may have been active participants.

In the last two days there have been fewer reports of violent attacks but some continue. Claims that the situation is stable are belied by the extremely tense standoff that remains. Ethnic Uzbeks who remain in Osh are in some cases trapped in isolated neighborhoods, living in fear behind barricades. The government itself recognizes that new violence could flare at any moment.

The humanitarian situation is grave and increasingly urgent because Kyrgyz forces cannot be relied upon to provide the secure environment needed for humanitarian assistance to reach the population. Humanitarian organizations are having great difficulty accessing those needing assistance, and report incidents of theft and looting of aid.

Some 100,000 ethnic Uzbeks have sought refuge in Uzbekistan; the border is now closed. As many as 40,000 who fled the violence are without shelter, and given the destruction of hundreds of houses, many of the displaced have no homes to return to even should they feel safe to do so. Repatriation of the displaced will require much greater security and confidence within the displaced community.

International security assistance is urgently needed. An international stabilization mission of limited size could make a significant difference by securing the area for humanitarian relief, providing security for some of the displaced to return home, and creating space for reconciliation, confidence-building, and mediation programs to succeed. This mission would have a policing mandate and could be bolstered by military forces, particularly constabulary forces or gendarmes, if necessary.

Security Council Members should work without delay with regional organizations to ensure that such a mission is fielded as quickly as possible, with the endorsement of the Security Council and with specific terms of reference, clear rules of engagement, and a limited duration. Countries with capacity to engage quickly, in particular Russia, should be encouraged to contribute to the rapid deployment of such a mission.

A short-term security presence is crucial to establishing the humanitarian corridor requested by the United Nations and should lead the way for multilateral efforts to create a secure political environment for the eventual, but delayed, holding of a constitutional referendum and elections, and a longer-term effort to strengthen the rule of law and the protection of minorities, as well as to assist the government in security-sector reform.

Accountability for the recent violence, including on the part of state authorities, will be essential to securing long-term stability and reconciliation. The government should be encouraged to investigate crimes, ensure the protection of witnesses, and hold accountable those responsible for the violence. Given the extent and character of the violence, however, government efforts toward accountability should have an international component to be credible and effective. As an immediate step, the government should cooperate with OHCHR to begin investigations.

The instability in southern Kyrgyzstan cannot be wished away, and without a decisive international response there is considerable risk that widespread violence will reignite. It is possible that ethnic Kyrgyz and Uzbeks may seek violent revenge for the past week of mayhem. Prolonged insecurity could provide an opening, for example, for political opponents who may seek to further weaken or overthrow the provisional government through violence against its perceived supporters. In the absence of an international mission to restore law and order, further such violence is likely to continue and could spill over to neighboring countries. Should conditions persist, widespread violence could cause a complete collapse of the state, with the attendant hum an rights, political, and security consequences for the region, including the risk of unilateral intervention by outside actors.

The threat to regional peace and security posed by the crisis in Kyrgyzstan is real and, despite the reduction in daily violence, still growing. The Security Council has an obligation to respond to these risks and should act immediately to work with the government, regional organizations and others to prevent further escalation of violence, including by authorizing international law enforcement and security assistance.

Best regards,

Louise Arbour, President and CEO, International Crisis Group

Kenneth Roth, Executive Director, Human Rights Watch

INTERNATIONAL CRISIS GROUP

Ещё один сайт на WordPress